Buy a Beer-Making Kit, Get a FREE Standard Refill.

Fall Brewing Starts Now | Shop Fall Brews

FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $99
Peanut Butter Fingers Stout
Peanut Butter Fingers Stout
Peanut Butter Fingers Stout
Peanut Butter Fingers Stout
Sold out

Peanut Butter Fingers Stout

Peanut Butter Fingers Stout

4.5
Rated 4.5 out of 5 stars
17 Reviews

SKU: 26500

$38.34
$38.34 $45.10

Out of stock

Brew in About 30 Minutes
Great Beer, Every Time
Proven Brewing Process
  • Free Shipping over $99
  • No-Sweat Returns
  • Top-Rated Customer Service

Peanut Butter Fingers Stout is a rich, creamy stout packed with smooth peanut butter flavor, roasty malt depth, and just enough sweetness to make every sip feel like dessert in a glass.

  • Big peanut butter flavor from 6.5 oz of PB2 powder
  • Creamy body and soft sweetness from lactose and BrewMax Golden LME
  • Roasty stout backbone from St. Patrick's Irish Stout extract and Chocolate Malt
  • Smooth malt complexity from Crystal 40 and Vienna Malt

This is one of those beers people remember. Brew it once, share a few bottles, and don’t be surprised when everyone wants to get their hands on your Peanut Butter Fingers Stout.

Contains Lactose: This recipe includes lactose, a milk-derived sugar. In a finished 2-gallon batch, that equals about 0.25 oz, or 7 g, per 16 oz pint. If you are sensitive to lactose or avoid milk-derived ingredients, select a lactose-free recipe instead.
Contains Peanut Ingredient: This recipe calls for peanut butter powder provided by the brewer. If you have a peanut allergy or avoid peanut ingredients, select a peanut-free recipe instead.

Your Brew Breakdown

Everything you need to craft your perfect brew

STORY

Overview: Peanut Butter Fingers Stout is a bold dessert-style stout built around rich peanut butter flavor, roasty malt character, and a smooth creamy finish. It is a standout recipe for brewers who want something unique, flavorful, and seriously share-worthy.

PROFILE

Tasting Notes: Expect a dark, full-bodied stout with peanut butter aroma, roasted malt depth, chocolate notes, and a soft sweetness from lactose. PB2 powder brings the peanut butter character, while St. Patrick's Irish Stout extract, Golden LME, and specialty grains create a rich malt base.

WHAT YOU GET

  • Ingredient: 1 Can St. Patrick's Irish Stout Brewing Extract (HME)
  • Ingredient: 2 Packets BrewMax Golden LME
  • Ingredient: 1 Packet BrewMax Booster
  • Ingredient: 1 Packet Crystal 40
  • Ingredient: 1 Packet Vienna Malt
  • Ingredient: 1 Packet Chocolate Malt
  • Ingredient: 1 Packet Lactose
  • Ingredient: 1 Hop Sack
  • Ingredient: 1 Packet S-04 Dry Ale Yeast
  • Ingredient: 1 Packet No-Rinse Cleanser

YOU PROVIDE

Ingredient: 6.5 oz PB2 Powder

FOR FANS OF

Beer: Belching Beaver Peanut Butter Milk Stout

Beer Style: Peanut butter stouts

Beer Style: Milk stouts

Beer Style: Dessert-style dark ales

BREW SPECS

Style: Stouts & Porters
Flavor: Creamy, malty, peanut butter, and chocolate
Original Gravity: 1.065
Final Gravity: 1.020
ABV: 5.93%
SRM (Color): 42
IBU (Bitterness): 48
Batch Size: 8 liters / about 2 gallons

BREW TIME

Total Time: Ready to enjoy in about 5–6 weeks

Fermentation: 3 weeks

Carbonation: 2 weeks

Conditioning Note: Additional conditioning can help the peanut butter, chocolate, and roasted malt flavors smooth out even more.

WHY THIS RECIPE

Why Brew It: This recipe is perfect for brewers who want a stout that is rich, creamy, and different from the usual dark beer lineup. PB2 powder adds big peanut butter character, lactose brings sweetness and body, and the stout base keeps everything roasty, smooth, and balanced.

Step-by-step brewing guide

How to Brew Peanut Butter Fingers Stout

DETAILED

Brew Day Guide

We’ll guide you every step of the way — no experience needed.

Detailed Instructions
BEFORE YOU BREW

Questions? We’ve Got Answers.

Get the details on what’s included, how it works, and what to expect from this product.
4.5
Rated 4.5 out of 5 stars
Based on 17 reviews
Total 5 star reviews: 11 Total 4 star reviews: 4 Total 3 star reviews: 2 Total 2 star reviews: 0 Total 1 star reviews: 0
88%would recommend this product
Slide 1 selected
Write a Review (Opens in a new window)
17 reviews
  • A
    Anonymous
    Verified Buyer
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    1 year ago
    Peanut Butter Fingers Stout with 2x PB2 powder

    My immediate reaction to this brew’s flavor was that this very likely a Top Tier recipe that I should brew again sometime at least this year. This is a very good-tasting beer that I would be happy to share with others. My niece and nephew both suggested that I try duplicating a peanut butter stout that we tried at a brewery last year so I finally tried to come through with this one. This is also a high ABV brew (especially with 2x the PB2 powder) with an alcoholic content of about 7.47%. I need to plan to buy and make another brew of this beer in time for Thanksgiving which imply brewing that beer by early August of this year. Note: Whereas the original recipe calls for 6.5 oz. of PB2 Powdered Peanut Butter I used double this amount (13 oz.) based on other reviews of this beer. Basically an excellent beer.

    Was this helpful?
  • A
    Anonymous
    Verified Buyer
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    10 months ago
    Peanut butter fingers milk stout

    Excellent. Just enough peanut butter taste but not too much and again just enough sweetness not too much. Very good beer. I did extend one week fermenting and one week of carbonation conditioning.

    Was this helpful?
  • A
    Anonymous
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    3 years ago
    Great Beer

    I opened the first one after 2 weeks in the bottle and it was really good. After 3 weeks it was great. After reading some of the reviews for the recipe I decided to add 2 oz of Peanut Butter extract at 10 days to get a real peanut butter hit and I definitely did. I followed the rest of the recipe and ingredients exactly as listed. This is a definite make again.

    Was this helpful?
  • A
    Anonymous
    Verified Buyer
    I recommend this product
    Rated 4 out of 5 stars
    4 years ago
    Recommendation to Double the PB2

    this is a solid beer but needs double what the recipe calls for in terms of PB2. Overall a fun beer to have around for people to try

    Was this helpful?
  • A
    Anonymous
    Verified Buyer
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    4 years ago
    Can't wait. This will probably be our favorite. ..

    Just brewing now. More time consuming to brew ... .

    Was this helpful?