Pennsylvania Chocolate Porter

Pennsylvania Chocolate Porter is rated 4.6 out of 5 by 32.
  • y_2024, m_6, d_24, h_5
  • bvseo_bulk, prod_bvrr, vn_bulk_3.0.42
  • cp_1, bvpage1
  • co_hasreviews, tv_16, tr_16
  • loc_en_US, sid_90-15320-00, prod, sort_[SortEntry(order=RELEVANCE, direction=DESCENDING)]
  • clientName_mrbeer
  • bvseo_sdk, p_sdk, 3.2.1
  • CLOUD, getAggregateRating, 7.84ms

Yes, yes, yes!!! This beer is all you want for the holidays. The perfect blend of malts and hops followed by just the right amount of sweetness from the chocolate. Before you know it you will be like that poor little chubby kid from Matilda but with chocolate beer all over your face, just slamming more and more beers until you can no longer stay upright and you fall face-first into an empty bottle of beers.

Customize Pennsylvania Chocolate Porter

* Required Fields

Your Customization
Pennsylvania Chocolate Porter
Pennsylvania Chocolate Porter

In stock

Subscription details



    What You Get

    1 American Porter Brewing Extract (HME)

    1 Packet of Smooth LME

    1 Packet of Chocolate Malt

    1 Packet of Crystal 40

    1 Packet of Crystal 60

    2 Packets of cocoa nibs 

    1 Packet of Lactose

    3 Muslin Hop Sack

    1 Packet of S-04

    1 Packet of No-Rinse Cleanser

    You Provide 

    3 Tablespoons Hershey's Cocoa Powder

    1/3 cup Hershey's Chocolate Syrup & 2 Tablespoons of Vodka to Thin it Slightly 

    For Fans Of

    Yuengling Hershey’s Chocolate Porter

    Brew Specs

    Flavor: Sweet

    Original Gravity: 1.052

    Final Gravity: 1.016

    ABV: 4.75%

    SRM: (Color): 30

    IBU: (Bitterness): 41

    STEP 1: Sanitizing

    Cleaning is one of the most important steps in brewing. It kills microscopic bacteria, wild yeast, and molds that may cause off-flavors in your beer. Make certain to clean all equipment that comes in contact with your beer by following the directions below:

    1. Fill clean keg with warm water to line mark 1 on the back, then add ½ pack (about 1 tablespoon) of No-Rinse Cleanser and stir until dissolved. Once dissolved, the solution is ready to use. Save the remaining ½ of No-Rinse Cleanser because you will need it for bottling.

    2. Screw-on the lid and swirl the keg so that the cleaning solution makes contact with the entire interior of the keg, including the underside of the lid. Note that the ventilation notches under the lid may leak solution. Allow to sit for at least 2 minutes and swirl again.

    3. To clean the spigot, open it fully and allow the liquid to flow for 5 seconds and then close.

    4. Pour the rest of the solution from the keg into a large bowl. Place your spoon/whisk, can opener and measuring cup into the bowl to keep them cleaned throughout the brewing process. Leave them immersed for at least 2 minutes in cleaning solution prior to using.

    5. After all, surfaces have been thoroughly cleaned, do not rinse or dry the keg or utensils. Return lid to the top of the keg, proceed immediately to brewing.


    Brewing beer is the process of combining a starch source (in this case, a malt brewing extract) with yeast. Once combined, the yeast eats the sugars in the malt, producing alcohol and carbon dioxide (CO2). This process is called fermentation.

    1. Remove the yeast packet from under the lid of the can of Brewing Extract, then place the unopened can in hot tap water.

    2. Add the packets of Chocolate Malt, Crystal 40, and Crystal 60 to one of the hop sacks and tie closed so that the grain can flow freely within the sack.

    3. Add 8 cups of water to the pot. Bring the water to a temperature of 155-165 and hold the water at that temperature.

    4. One the temperature range is achieved, add in the grain sack and allow it to steep holding the temperature range for 30 minutes.

    5. After the 30-minute grain steep has passed remove from heat, rinse the hop sack in a colander with 1-2 cups of hot water, allowing the run-off to flow back into the pot. DO NOT SQUEEZE THE GRAIN SACK. Discard grain sack.

    6. Add one packet of cocoa nibs to a muslin sack and tie closed, set aside.

    7. Next, open the packet of LME and stir to dissolve. Then bring this mixture to a low boil. 

    8. Maintain this mixture at a low rolling boil. Once the mixture is boiling, add the Cocoa powder and lactose and stir until dissolved, maintain a low rolling boil. Next, add the sack with the cocoa nibs and allow to boil for 5 minutes. Once 5 minutes has passed remove the pot from heat. 

    9. Open the can of Brewing Extract and pour the contents into the hot mixture in your pot. Stir until thoroughly mixed. This mixture of unfermented beer is called wort.

    10. Fill your fermenter with cold tap water to the mark 1 on the back. If using any other fermenter this would be approximately 1 gallon of water.

    11. Pour the wort into your fermenter, and then bring the volume of the fermenter to mark 2 by adding more cold water. (If you have a different fermenter top it off to 8.5 liters)

    12. Stir your wort mixture vigorously with your sanitized spoon or whisk.

    13. Sprinkle the S-04 Dry Ale yeast packet into the keg, and screw on the lid. Do not stir.

    Put your fermenter in a location with a consistent temperature between 68° and 78° F (20°-25° C), and out of direct sunlight. Ferment for 14 days.

    STEP 3: Adding Extras 

    Adding extras is the process of adding additional ingredients to a beer which will impart more flavor and aroma in your finished brew.

    1. On day 7 of fermentation, sanitize the 3rd hopsack and add in the cocoa nibs and tie closed. Set aside.

    2. Next, add the 1/3 cup of Hershey’s syrup to a sanitized jar or bowl and add the two tablespoons of vodka and stir with a sanitized spoon.

    3. Add the chocolate syrup mixture and the sack with cocoa nibs into the fermenter and allow to ferment for 7 more days. (you do not need to stir)

    STEP 4: Bottling & Carbonating

    After 14 days, taste a small sample to determine if the beer is fully fermented and ready to bottle. If it tastes like flat beer, it is ready. If it’s sweet, then it’s not ready. Let it ferment for 3 more days (17 total). At this point, it is time to bottle. Do not let it sit in the fermenter for longer than 24 days total.

    1. When your beer is ready to bottle, fill a 1-gallon container with warm water, then add the remaining ½ pack of the No-Rinse Cleanser and stir until dissolved. Once dissolved, it is ready to use.

    2. Distribute the cleaning solution equally among the bottles. Screw-on caps (or cover with a metal cap if using glass bottles) and shake bottles vigorously. Allow to sit 10 minutes, then shake the bottles again. Remove caps and empty all cleaning solution into a large bowl. Use this solution to clean any other equipment you may be used for bottling. Do not rinse.

    3. Add 2 Carbonation Drops to each 740-mL bottle. For 1-liter bottles, add 2 ½ drops; for ½-liter bottles add 1 drop. Alternatively, you can add table sugar using this table as a guide

    4. Holding the bottle at an angle, fill each bottle to about 2 inches from the bottle’s top.

    5. Place caps on bottles, hand tighten, and gently turn the bottle over to check the bottle’s seal. It is not necessary to shake them.

    6. Store the bottles upright and out of direct sunlight in a location with a consistent temperature between 70°-76°F or 21°-24°C. Allow sitting for a minimum of 14 days. If the temperature is cooler than suggested it may take an additional week to reach full carbonation. 

    Tip from our Brewmasters

    After the primary carbonation has taken place your beer is ready to drink. We recommend putting 1 bottle in the refrigerator at first for 48 hrs. After 48hrs. give it a try and if it is up to your liking put the rest of your beer in the fridge. If it does not taste quite right, leave the bottles out at room temp for another week or so. Keep following this method until your brew tastes just how you like it. 

    This process is called conditioning and during this time the yeast left in your beer can help clean up any off flavors. Almost everything gets a little better with time and so will your beer.

    Rated 5 out of 5 by Mark in Colorado from Can't go wrong with these kits. Sadly, I cannot purchase Yuengling products in Colorado. I don't know how Mr. Beer does it but the "clone" recipe kits are excellent. My wife likes the Pennsylvania Chocolate Porter better than the 'real thing'. I like making and drinking them as well. The ingredients were fresh, and the instructions were easy. Can't go wrong with these kits.
    Date published: 2021-01-28
    Rated 4 out of 5 by John Bar from Service I paid for expedited shipping but it shipped on the day a 20pct discount appeared. I paid before the discount so I didn’t receive it. Dissapointing. I also had to make a second order as no sugar tabs were included.
    Date published: 2021-12-27
    Rated 5 out of 5 by B beer from Best ever! This was my first time brewing a "more complicated" recipe, so I wasn't sure what to expect. I followed the directions perfectly and it turned out to be the best beer that I have ever made, excellent product!
    Date published: 2022-06-19
    Rated 5 out of 5 by Chris d from Stepping up your game If you’re looking to step up your brewing, I want a great recipe to do it with this is your recipe. Love the flavors in hell turned out
    Date published: 2020-11-05
    Rated 5 out of 5 by GeorgeWF from Similar to Yuengling Hershey Porter ... Yeah!! I haven't brewed this yet but am eager to do so. I will as soon as my fermenter finishes the current batch. I really like Yuengling Hershey Porter. This is supposed to be close. Yuengling Hershey Porter is hard to find. In fact, it may no longer be made.
    Date published: 2024-04-05
    Rated 5 out of 5 by Shrike from A Great Autumn Beer I wasn't really sure what to expect with this, but it's just great. It's an exceptionally smooth and well balanced porter; the chocolate does not overpower the taste, hits a bit on the after taste, then slowly fades. I'll brew this one again.
    Date published: 2021-10-27
    Rated 5 out of 5 by rap82 from A worthy clone I made this at the request of my daughter-in-law. The Yuengling Hershey’s chocolate porter is one of her favorites. Now the Mr. Beer version is as well. Fun to make, came out perfectly, and fun to drink.
    Date published: 2021-10-11
    Rated 4 out of 5 by JonB from PA Chocolate Porter Only 4-stars as it's still in the keg! It was easy to make, instructions were very clear, and if smell means anything, all the ingredients were fresh (and the wort smelled great as well!)
    Date published: 2022-03-31
    • y_2024, m_6, d_24, h_5
    • bvseo_bulk, prod_bvrr, vn_bulk_3.0.42
    • cp_1, bvpage1
    • co_hasreviews, tv_16, tr_16
    • loc_en_US, sid_90-15320-00, prod, sort_[SortEntry(order=RELEVANCE, direction=DESCENDING)]
    • clientName_mrbeer
    • bvseo_sdk, p_sdk, 3.2.1
    • CLOUD, getReviews, 7.97ms

    Which cocoa powder is more recommended, milk chocolate or dark chocolate?

    Asked by: Gavan3
    That's a great question. Usually, we'll recommend getting the 'purest' cocoa, something without additives, so you can maximize the cocoa flavor. However, as long as it isn't loaded with preservatives, you can explore any kind of cocoa you like. I just recommend taking notes, so if you love it (or hate it) you'll know how to do it again (or not).
    Answered by: Mr Beer
    Date published: 2023-03-16

    When you purchase the recipe does it come with instructions?

    Asked by: Twisted Tim
    The instructions for each recipe are available to print on that recipes page, under the "instructions" tab. Thank you!
    Answered by: MRBEER
    Date published: 2022-04-19

    How long should this one be aged? Lots of flavors in there.

    Asked by: MarkE
    Hello! We really enjoy this beer aged between 4-6 weeks. Cheers!
    Answered by: MRBEER
    Date published: 2021-11-01

    To boost the ABV when using St Patrick's HMW instead, which LME should I use?

    Asked by: GFstout
    Pale or smooth would work nicely. Cheers!
    Answered by: MRBEER
    Date published: 2021-08-26

    Will this recipe work using the St. Patrick's HME? I would also like to raise the ABV by 1.5%

    Asked by: GFstout
    Hello, yes, this could work with the St. Patrick's HME. To increase the ABV, You could add an additional LME, or two. Cheers!
    Answered by: MRBEER
    Date published: 2021-08-26

    How would you get more of a chocolate flavor with out making it bitter?

    Asked by: Laser designs by mike
    You could steep a little more chocolate malt in the recipe that would add a little more of that chocolate flavor.
    Answered by: RobertMrBeer
    Date published: 2021-06-01

    After step 8, do I transfer the first muslin sack of cocoa nibs I boiled for 5 minutes to the fermentor with the wort? There is no mention of taking it out or leaving it in anywhere.

    Asked by: JoeV
    If we do not instruct you to take it out then you will transfer that to the fermenter.
    Answered by: RobertMrBeer
    Date published: 2023-09-04
    • y_2024, m_6, d_23, h_7CST
    • bvseo_bulk, prod_bvqa, vn_bulk_3.0.42
    • cp_1, bvpage1
    • co_hasquestionsanswers, tq_7
    • loc_en_US, sid_90-15320-00, prod, sort_[SortEntry(order=LAST_APPROVED_ANSWER_SUBMISSION_TIME, direction=DESCENDING)]
    • clientName_mrbeer
    • bvseo_sdk, p_sdk, 3.2.1
    • CLOUD, getContent, 7.32ms